Why choose Keep It Sweet Desserts?
We pride ourselves in making the tastiest baked goods. Each recipe has been thoroughly tested (and tasted!) to make sure the flavors and textures are crowd pleasers. Everything is baked from scratch!
Cookie Cakes
How big are your cookie cakes?
The standard cookie cakes are 12 inches and serve 10 to 16 people generously! Mini cookie cakes in our holiday gift box are 6 inches and serve 3 to 4 people, each. Party hack with kids: cut the cookie cake like a grid to get more servings
Do you personalize the cookie cakes?
We are happy to personalize your standard-size cookie cake.
Dessert Platters
What sweet treats do you offer for your dessert platters?
You can choose 2-3 baked goods for your dessert platter. Options include:
- Black and White Blondies
- Fudgy Caramel Brown
- Salted Caramel Bars
- Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Triple Chocolate Cookies
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
- Vanilla Bean Sprinkle Cookies
- S’mores Cookies (available seasonally)
- Fudgy S’mores Brownies (available seasonally)
How many people does a dessert platter feed?
A dessert platter includes a selection of small-sized cookies and bars for 12-15 people. One platter costs $55
Other Items
Do you offer cookie boxes?
We do have cookie boxes available by the dozen via special order as well as seasonal pop-up options. For a quick turnaround, order Black and White Blondies or Chocolate Chip Cookies
Are the desserts nut-free?
Most of our recipes do NOT include nuts. However, everything is produced in a facility that processes peanuts, tree nuts, soy and sesame. Most of our baked goods contain wheat, dairy and eggs
What are your most popular desserts?
Our Black and White Cookie Cake is our current best seller
Logistics
How do I place an order?
You can order a cookie cake via order form or by contacting us over Instagram or email. Details here!
Where are you located?
All pick-ups are in Tenafly, NJ. You will get the exact address upon making your payment. Local delivery may be arranged if available
What is the shelf life of the desserts?
All of our baked goods are best enjoyed within 2 days. However, they freeze extremely well! Simply freeze your cookie cakes in their box tightly closed or your cookies / bars in an airtight container for up to 3 months. Defrost at room temperature for two hours and enjoy!
How far in advance do I need to place an order?
Typical orders may require up to one week advance notice. We will do our best to fill an order faster than that! Large size catering orders may require additional notice
What is the order cancellation policy?
You can cancel your order up to 3 days in advance for a store credit.
Where do you ship?
We don’t currently ship our baked goods. Right now we offer pickups and delivery in North Jersey