Cookie Cakes

The birthday cake that never has leftovers

A giant bakery-fresh cookie, decorated and personalized for your celebration. Chewy, flavorful, delicious and more fun than a cake — and always the first dessert gone.

From $37.50 · Personalized message included · Serves 10-16

Made for

  • Birthday parties (kids and grown-ups)
  • Family gatherings & Shabbat dinners
  • Camp visiting day
  • Office celebrations
  • Mahjong nights
  • Bed Parties for high school grads!

How it works

  1. Order 7 days ahead using our quick form or e-mail
  2. Choose your flavor and message — (Chocolate Chip, M&M Chocolate Chip, Black and White, S’mores)
  3. Pick up in Tenafly or ask about delivery.

“Cake was 10/10! TYSM” — Rachael, Tenafly

Order Your Cookie Cake!

*Check back for different flavors throughout the year!*

Cookie cakes, dessert platters, pop-ups and more!