These days, it is very rare that I make a dessert recipe a second time. Other than what I am selling, I like to constantly try new things and am always on a mission to share something new and creative with you.
But sometimes, your friends and family cling onto that cookie you made and ask you about it every time you see them for an ENTIRE YEAR. Never mind that the recipe takes all of 20 minutes to put together. Never mind that there is pre-made cookie dough involved. Never mind that I’ve baked you cakes that take HOURS until they are in their final form. Seriously, why are the easiest desserts sometimes the biggest hits? This is a frustrating but wonderful thing all at the same time.
So when Peep season started again I finally caved and made these cookies for a second time. I have to admit, there is something irresistible about a giant cookie oozing with a gooey melted peep right out of the oven. Stick some salty pretzel in there and you really do have a winner.
Want to make these cookies for your Easter celebration or just because you can’t stock up on Peeps fast enough while they are everywhere you turn? Go get the recipe here!
Anything that involves melting peeps is a good thing
OMG, how inventive. They look amazing. Your new site is beautiful.
Thanks, Jennie!
Hehehe how cute!
Now that’s ooey-gooey looking! Genius :)
What a great way to use Peeps! And the addition of pretzels is great, I think people should bake with pretzels more often. Plus I love how in the first picture the pretzel sort of looks like a halo around the bunny’s head :)
lol I didn’t notice that!
On one hand these cookies look and sound amazing! On the other hand I am some what disturbed that the poor peep has been melted, LOL! I would love for you to link up to my Muffin Top Blog Hop!
Yum! Slightly murderous, but yummy! ;)
Haha!
I just perused all of your new site–I am so excited for you and everything looks so so SO delicious!!
This cookie looks the perfect mix of sweet and salty and chewy and sticky. Amazing!
mmm…what a creative idea for Easter dessert!
Given my adoration of peeps…how do I NOT remember these? I think I’m losing my mind in my older age. :)
I was just trying to think up ways to bake with peeps! Great recipe!
I’ve never put pretzels into a cookie but now I really want to try! Yum!
The Matzoh Crack looks so delicious. I’d love try it!
I don’t normally like Peeps, but melted in a cookie? You might change my mind!
I kind of feel like you killed the poor bunnies. It’s OK though I was never a huge fan of Peeps. I just got a package though as a gift and I think I just might experiment with cookies like these. I love the new site!
Holy moly, I’d be counting down the days until peep season :) I don’t make many recipes twice either…but the ones that repeat are as fantastic as this!
What is not to like?! I really need to make these…perhaps for this coming weekend!
OMG your new website looks so fabulous! Wonderful job! Also, I am loving this peep recipe. I actually am not a fan of peeps but peeps inside a cookie sound wonderful! Congrats to you! xoxo
SUCH a cute idea. I love Peeps so I don’t know how many would end up in the cookies as opposed to my mouth, but I should totally give it a shot :D Thanks for sharing!
I love peeps SO MUCH and would absolutely adore these cookies. Now I know what to do with all my leftovers!