Close-up of a chocolate chip cookie cake decorated with rainbow sprinkles and small whipped cream swirls with sprinkles, on a white marble surface.

The birthday cake that never has leftovers.

Giant bakery-fresh cookie cakes, decorated and personalized for your celebration. From $40.

Order a Cookie Cake Below
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Oreos and Brownie Batter!
The special Keep It Sweet Desserts Black and White Cookie Cake
Birthday Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

Available flavors: Chocolate Chip, Black & White, Triple Decker (NEW!), Pumpkin Chocolate Chip, Sweet & Salty Halloween

Each cookie cake serves 10–16

Personalized message included

Order 7 days ahead, pickup in Tenafly; local delivery within 5 miles may be available

What customers are saying…

“Thank you for the cookie cake. It was a HUGE hit! Everyone loved it” — Micki, Tenafly

“Well, needless to say, cookie cake was a big hit!” — Pamela, Tenafly

Questions or something custom? DM @keepitsweetdesserts or e-mail us.