Cookies, blondies & brownies

For every gathering! Signature cookie platters and boxes for holidays, gifts, camp visiting day, and every 'I should bring something' moment. Baked in Tenafly.

Order a Cookie Platter

Special desserts for a sweet New Year!

Order a Cookie Box
High Holiday Desserts

Cookie Platters

Dessert platter with fudgy caramel brownies, vanilla bean sprinkle cookies, blondies and chocolate chip cookies

Perfect for parties, showers, and gatherings

Serves 12–15 people

Choose 2–3 flavors

$60 per platter

Order a Cookie Platter
High Holiday Dessert Platters

Cookie Boxes

One dozen of your favorite flavor

Great for gifts, hostess presents, and treats

From $32/dozen

Order a Cookie Box
Big Crumb Cookies for the Holidays
Brown butter cookies that taste like NYC crumb cake

Big Crumb Cookie Box

Oversized, bakery-style cookies packed with texture and flavor — big crumb, big taste. Perfect for gifting or treating yourself to something extra.

$30 for 6 jumbo cookies

BIG Crumb Cookie Box

Flavors

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Vanilla Bean Sprinkle Cookies

Black & White Blondies

Fudgy Caramel Brownies

Salted Caramel Bars

Triple Chocolate Cookies

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

Snickerdoodle Cookies

Lemon Sparkle Cookies

Summer Specials:

S’mores Cookies, S’mores Brownies

Fall Specials:

Pumpkin Pie Chocolate Chip Blondies, Halloween Cookies

“And omg the salted caramel bar!!!!! It was soooo delish” — Catherine, Westfield

“Just made ice cream sandwiches with your cookies!! Delicious!!” — Courteney, Tenafly

Perfect for: Holidays · Camp visiting day · Hostess gifts · Shiva & sympathy · Office celebrations

Order a Cookie Platter
Order a Cookie Box
High Holiday Desserts

Questions? DM @keepitsweetdesserts or email us