0

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie Cakes are back for Thanksgiving! Order by 11/21.

Skip to Content
Keep It Sweet Desserts
Home
Order
Cookie Cakes
Platters & Cookie Boxes
Parties & Events
Party Favors
Corporate Gifts
About
FAQ
Contact
Recipes
Order Now
Keep It Sweet Desserts
Home
Order
Cookie Cakes
Platters & Cookie Boxes
Parties & Events
Party Favors
Corporate Gifts
About
FAQ
Contact
Recipes
Order Now
Home
Order
Cookie Cakes
Platters & Cookie Boxes
Folder: Parties & Events
Back
Parties & Events
Party Favors
Corporate Gifts
About
FAQ
Contact
Recipes
Order Now
No results found
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 7/13/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 7/13/26

Double Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 7/11/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 7/11/26

Pumpkin Cinnamon Bun Ice Cream (No Churn)

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 7/11/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 7/11/26

Drumstick Ice Cream Cake

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/28/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/28/26

Graham and Milk Chocolate Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/26/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/26/26

No Churn Oreo Fudge Swirl Ice Cream

Read More
Bars, Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/21/26 Bars, Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/21/26

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream Bars

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/19/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/19/26

New York Crumb Cake Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/5/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/5/26

Speculoos Sundae with Warm Blueberry Sauce

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/2/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 6/2/26

No-Churn Cookie Butter Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 5/26/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 5/26/26

Peanut Butter Ripple Chocolate Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 5/24/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 5/24/26

Cinnamon Bun Cookie Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 5/2/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 5/2/26

Peanut Butter Chocolate Covered Pretzel Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 3/9/26 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 3/9/26

Monster Cookie Dough Ice Cream (No Churn!)

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 10/12/25 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 10/12/25

Pumpkin Cookie Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 9/1/25 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 9/1/25

Vanilla Ice Cream with Salty Candied Peanuts and Dark Chocolate

Read More
Ice Cream, Bars Lauren Lilling 8/21/25 Ice Cream, Bars Lauren Lilling 8/21/25

Fudgy Brownie Ice Cream Sandwiches

Read More
Ice Cream, Fruit Desserts Lauren Lilling 8/17/25 Ice Cream, Fruit Desserts Lauren Lilling 8/17/25

Gingersnap Peach Crumble Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 8/4/25 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 8/4/25

No Churn Lemon Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 8/3/25 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 8/3/25

No Churn Blueberry Crisp Ice Cream

Read More
Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 8/1/25 Ice Cream Lauren Lilling 8/1/25

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Read More

Keep It Sweet Desserts

Tenafly, NJ

Serving Bergen County

Newsletter Block
This newsletter signup form needs a storage option. Edit the block and enter a storage location via the Storage tab.

Stay Up to Date

Seasonal flavors, holidays specials and more. One or two emails a month.

We respect your privacy.

You're in! Look for one or two emails a month — seasonal flavors, ordering reminders and more.

Order

FAQ

Contact Us